Ruth Hines Gardner died on June 14, 2003. Born on December 27, 1928, Ruth Gardner was a pioneer. By today’s standards she would be one of many great women who realize their vocations as minister of music. However, in post-war America as Rosie the Riveter went back to the household, few female organists/church musicians were relegated to high-profile positions and leadership. In spite of these odds, Ruth triumphed throughout her life as a Christian and a church musician.
Ruth was a young piano and organ student in Wilmington, Delaware, where she was a parishioner of the Cathedral Church of St. John. She later attended the Curtis Institute on scholarship in 1946. She was the only woman in a class of organists that included such names as David Craighead, Donald McDonald, and George Markey, all of whom studied with the legendary Alexander McCurdy. While at Curtis Institute, Ruth encountered the young Gian Carlo Menotti as a theory professor and even dated classmate and upcoming conductor Thomas Schippers. There are many stories that circulate about Ruth being the only female presence in the organ studio at Curtis. These times were not especially kind to women preparing to work in the church.
Ruth was noted for her ability to conduct and play. She was an expert organist in the great oratorio style. She learned this amazing skill to accompany the Mozart and Brahms Requiems as well as the B Minor Mass at McCurdy’s elbow when she was the assistant to Dr. McCurdy. After Curtis, Ruth obtained her first job in rural Virginia at a Baptist church. Marriage and a family called her back to Delaware in the early 1950s and claimed most of her attention until the early 1970s, when she entered church work again in Main Line Philadelphia and finally at Immanuel on the Green, New Castle. Ruth Gardner was no “Miss Suzie” as her rector, The Rev. Edward Godden would describe. Ruth was always looking forward yet was mindful of the tradition of the Church. Her organ recital programs always embraced Bach and contemporaries such as Messiaen and Leighton, and she frequently played from memory. When a terrible fire destroyed Immanuel on the Green in 1982, Ruth engineered the choice of Ned Rorem as composer of Immanuel’s anthem of rededication. Subsequent musical commissions included Gerre Hancock and Jack Burnam.
I met Ruth in the mid 1990s as I inherited her mantle at Immanuel Church. I could not have imagined a gentler or kinder gift. Immanuel Church couldn’t have been more prepared: a wonderful, expressive organ, a delightful historic building, a marvelous rector and a congregation and choir that could sing Anglican Chant from the Coverdale Psalter. As I worked with Ruth on the King’s College Training Course of the RSCM, I learned more important lessons: a dedication to the art and craft of church music and a dedication to the living God. A graduate of Education for Ministry (EFM), Ruth explored her faith in this ever-changing world.
Ruth was diagnosed with ovarian cancer in January 2003. After a short bout with chemotherapy, Ruth opted not to pursue treatment. In June she died while being taken care of by her family and close friends at Immanuel on the Green in New Castle after 74 years of faithful service to God, the Church, her family & friends, and her vocation.
—Jeffery Johnson
Grace Church, New York
Dean Robinson died on January 31 at the age of 78 in Rochester, Minnesota. He was carillonneur of the Rochester Carillon since 1958, and only the second carillonneur to hold that post in 75 years. Born on July 16, 1925 in Mazeppa, Minnesota, he graduated from Mazeppa High School before serving in the U.S. Navy. He then earned a bachelor’s degree from Oberlin Conservatory, Oberlin, Ohio, and a master of music degree from MacPhail College of Music in Minneapolis. He served as minister of music at Montgomery Baptist Church, Montgomery, Alabama, before returning to Mazeppa where he opened his own studio, later moving it to Rochester. He was appointed carillonneur of the Rochester Carillon in 1958 and became a member of the Guild of Carillonneurs of North America in 1961. He was a founding member of the Southeast Minnesota AGO chapter, and was an active member of the United Methodist Church in Mazeppa, where he played the organ for over 50 years. His recitals took him throughout the United States and Canada. A memorial service took place on February 11 at Calvary Episcopal Church, Rochester, with organists Robert Scoggin and Brian Williams, carillonneurs Jeffrey Daehn, Jeanine Hadley, and Bruce Rohde, the Calvary Motet Choir, and two handbell ringers.
The Rev. Dr. Victor Ira Zuck of Hagerstown, Maryland, died January 6 at the Homewood Retirement Center in Williamsport, Maryland. He was 95. Born in Hagerstown, January 29, 1908, he attended Blue Ridge College, New Windsor, Maryland. For a number of years, he was employed by M.P. Möller Organ Co. of Hagerstown, leaving during the Great Depression to perfect the second commercially successful electronic organ, known as The Orgatron, that was built and distributed by The Everett Piano Co., South Haven, Michigan. During World War II, manufacturing and patent rights were leased to the Rudolph Wurlitzer Co., North Tonawanda, New York, and when they expired in 1952, Mr. Zuck became regional manager and sales representative for M.P. Möller in Hagerstown. He was also president of Victor I. Zuck, Pipe Organs, Pittsburgh.
In his late 60s, he continued his studies for the priesthood at Trinity School for Ministry, and after ordination, served a number of churches in the Diocese of Pittsburgh. One of his great achievements while in Pittsburgh was the raising of money for the restoration of the Mother Church in the Diocese of Pittsburgh, dating from 1765, for which he received a prodigious award from The Pittsburgh History and Landmarks Foundation. During a sabbatical in 1982–83, he attended Trinity Theological Seminary, graduating in 1984 as a doctor of ministry, summa cum laude. In September 1988, he returned to his hometown to enjoy partial retirement and became a member of the Collegium of Pastoral Associates at St. John’s Episcopal Church in Hagerstown. He was a member of the American Guild of Organists, the Organ Historical Society, the American Theater Organ Society and many other organizations, and wrote many articles for miscellaneous publications. Dr. Zuck made seven trips to Europe, Asia and the Middle East from 1956 to 1976. He is survived by his wife, the former Nathalie Peterson of New York City, one daughter, four grandsons, and five great-grandchildren.
